PSA vs Beckett Grading: Which Should You Choose?
PSA and Beckett are the two most recognized professional grading services for trading cards. They use different scales and subgrades, which matters for the grade you receive and what buyers expect when you sell.
How the grading scales differ
PSA uses a whole-number 1 to 10 scale with no half-points. Beckett (BGS) also uses 1 to 10 but allows half-points (so 9.5 is a possible grade) and assigns four subgrades: centering, corners, edges and surface. The final BGS grade is the lowest of the four subgrades, rounded to the nearest half-point. PSA gives one composite grade with no subgrade breakdown.
What PSA is best known for
- By total volume, PSA grades more cards than any other service.
- PSA is the dominant choice for vintage sports cards and Pokemon cards.
- The clean 1 to 10 whole-number scale is easy to compare across cards and sellers.
- PSA 10 (Gem Mint) is the most recognized top-grade label in the hobby.
What Beckett (BGS) is best known for
- BGS is widely used for modern sports cards, particularly in segments of the basketball and football card market.
- The BGS Black Label (all four subgrades at 10) is considered the rarest and most prestigious grade in the hobby.
- Half-points allow more differentiation: a BGS 9.5 sits between PSA 9 and PSA 10 in many buyers' minds.
- Subgrade transparency: you can see exactly which aspect of the card lost points.
Cost and turnaround
Both services offer tiered pricing based on card value and turnaround speed. Standard (economy) turnaround runs weeks to several months depending on demand. Express and walk-through tiers cost significantly more. Prices change frequently, so check each service's current fee schedule before submitting. For standard submissions, fees are in a broadly similar range between the two services.
Which to choose
If you are grading vintage cards, sports cards you plan to resell, or Pokemon cards, PSA is typically the more liquid choice: more buyers recognize the PSA scale and graded PSA cards trade in larger volumes. If the specific market segment you care about values BGS subgrades, or you want the transparent subgrade breakdown, BGS is worth considering. For most collectors starting out, PSA is the more straightforward choice.
Card Scanner helps you scan and look up card values so you know which cards are worth grading before you submit. For more on the grading decision, see the article on whether you should grade your cards.
Common questions
- Is a PSA 10 better than a BGS 9.5?
- In market terms, a PSA 10 often commands a higher premium for most cards because PSA 10 is widely recognized as the top grade. A BGS 9.5 is a strong grade and may be preferred by some collectors who value the subgrade transparency, but PSA 10s typically have a larger audience of buyers.
- Can you get a card re-graded by the other company?
- Yes. You can submit a BGS-graded card to PSA for grading (and vice versa), though the cost of cracking the slab and re-submitting needs to make financial sense. This is worth considering for high-value cards where switching services could change the market value.
- What other grading companies exist?
- Beyond PSA and Beckett, CGC (originally for comics, now grades cards) and SGC are significant alternatives. CGC has grown quickly in the Pokemon and vintage card market. Each service has its own scale and collector base, so check which is most relevant to your specific card category.
- Is raw (ungraded) card value much lower than graded?
- It depends on the card and the expected grade. A PSA 10 of a popular card can be worth many times the raw value. A PSA 6 card might be worth only a small premium over raw, or less when grading fees are factored in. The value of grading depends heavily on the specific card and the grade it is likely to receive.